Managing partners ask me, "Should we buy one of these AI products for lawyers?" It's the wrong question—and making the wrong choice could set your firm back years.
The AI Product Trap
Unlike purchasing case management software or time tracking applications, buying an off-the-shelf AI product for your law firm carries unique risks that most firms haven't considered. Traditional legal software handles defined processes with predictable inputs and outputs. AI systems, however, must learn your firm's judgment, priorities, and nuanced decision-making patterns.
When you purchase a pre-built AI product, you're asking your firm to conform to another company's interpretation of legal work. That might work for basic tasks, but it becomes problematic when the AI needs to understand your client communication style, document review priorities, or risk assessment approach.
Where AI Creates Real Value in Law Firms
The most successful AI implementations I've seen focus on specific, high-volume workflows where firms can see immediate impact:
Document Review and Analysis: Instead of reading every contract clause, AI can flag unusual terms, missing provisions, or potential risks based on your firm's specific criteria. But "unusual" according to whom? Your standards or the software vendor's?
Client Intake and Screening: AI can qualify leads, schedule consultations, and draft initial engagement letters. However, your firm's intake process reflects your market positioning and service philosophy—elements that generic software can't capture.
Legal Research and Case Analysis: AI excels at synthesizing case law and identifying relevant precedents. However, effective legal research depends on understanding your litigation strategy, your judge's preferences, and your client's risk tolerance.
Contract Generation and Review: Template contracts are table stakes now. The real value comes from AI that understands your negotiation patterns, clients' business models, and the firm's standard positions on key terms.
Discovery and eDiscovery: Beyond keyword searching, AI can identify patterns in communications, flag privileged documents, and prioritize review based on case strategy. But case strategy is uniquely yours.
The Three Paths Forward
Law firms today face three choices, each with distinct implications:
Do Nothing: The safest short-term choice, but you're watching competitors gain efficiency advantages while your costs continue rising. Associating hours spent on routine tasks becomes increasingly expensive compared to automated alternatives.
Buy a Product: Tempting because it feels like progress with minimal effort. But you're betting your firm's competitive advantage on a vendor's vision of legal practice. These products often promise quick wins but deliver rigid workflows that may not align with your client's expectations.
Partner for Custom Development: More complex initially, but allows you to automate your processes rather than adapting to someone else's. This approach treats AI implementation as a strategic advantage rather than a commodity purchase.
Why This Decision Is Different
Traditional legal software purchases involved well-defined functionality: case management, billing, and document storage. You could evaluate features, compare vendors, and make informed decisions based on precise requirements.
AI implementation is fundamentally different. The technology learns from your data, your decisions, and your priorities. A generic AI product trained on thousands of firms' data might work adequately for basic tasks, but it will never reflect your firm's unique expertise or client relationships.
The Incremental Approach
The most successful firms start with one workflow—often document review or client intake—and perfect the AI implementation before expanding. This incremental approach allows you to:
- Measure actual ROI before making larger investments
- Train your team on AI tools gradually
- Maintain quality control throughout the process
- Adjust the technology as your needs evolve
Making the Right Choice
Your next AI decision will shape your firm's competitive position for years. Before purchasing any AI product, ask yourself: Does this technology adapt to our practice, or are we adapting to it?
The firms that will thrive in the AI era view technology as a strategic differentiator, not just another software purchase. They're asking not "What AI product should we buy?" but "How can AI amplify what makes our firm unique?"
Your choice today determines whether AI becomes your competitive advantage or another software expense.
Grace Schroeder is the CEO of Slingr.io. Slingr helps law firms make strategic technology decisions. Contact her to discuss AI implementation strategies that align with your firm's unique practice.
.png)
.png)
.png)
